Description does not say that all floats should be rounded down. It even says to use integers, and not floats.

If you use floats in your solution, then the bug is introduced by you. There is no need for floats here, and avoiding them prevents rounding bugs.

Inconsistent rounding errors on some of the random tests, instructions suggest that all floats should be rounded down but some of the random test cases expect floats to round up

Which katas?

Rejected because I don't see how this kata can be translated to COBOL faithfully. The description asks to filter out numeric strings like "123". But it cannot be done in COBOL.

Random tests should be added.

• Random tests should be added.

• There should be a blank line at the end of the initial solution and at the end of Sample Tests (there should be no warnings).

Note: adding random tests seems to be an overkill for this task. But the main idea is that all translation should meet some minimum quality requirements.

• Random tests should be added.

• There should be a blank line at the end of the initial solution (there should be no warnings).

• I recommend to remove display from tests and display input values in test case titles. Here is an example:

           move 'testing' to s
           testcase 'Test 2, s = "' function trim(s) '"'.

@JJRG you can approve translations as you have more than 4,000 honor, as indicated here. Sadly, the translations authored by a user are not listed on their profile.

@Ott-gs when you author a translation, you should post a suggestion on the Discourse page of the kata, with a link to the translation. Otherwise, few people will notice it.

I'm sorry, but I don't think my profile has privileges to review and approve translations. I don't see an option that allows it and I can't see the translations you're talking about either.
:-(

A long time ago, I posted 4 translations for COBOL challenges, but I haven't received any updates. Would you be so kind as to give me your valuable time and check the translations?

Thank you in advance!

A long time ago, I posted 4 translations for COBOL challenges, but I haven't received any updates. Would you be so kind as to give me your valuable time and check the translations?

Thank you in advance!

A long time ago, I posted 4 translations for COBOL challenges, but I haven't received any updates. Would you be so kind as to give me your valuable time and check the translations?

Thank you in advance!

Thanks man!

Your explanation is very clear!

Hi, Ott.

Your solution is very clever! What's the name of that formula to find multiples??