Really cool Kata, I loved solving it, even though it took me a while. Keep making more like this.

Thank you very much, I have learned a lot from this experience. Sorry for wasting your time

Please can you tell me why you hated it, at least? Was it just because it was to similar or is it something I actually did wrong?

Ah, okay, thank you.
Should I unpublish? What do I do from here.

I said I thought. I am sorry that you think this is too similar, I have checked some, but not all. Most are just fixed shifts, they only move by one thing for each letter and is given a number. You say 'one if', but the only thing it shares is a name and the fact that they both encrypt letters. I am ONLY saying this from the ones I have seen, so please don't take my words out of context again, I may be wrong and I DO agree that there are already some ciphers out there. I just thought this would be a dun first kata for me to make.

I can't see that, for me it says (s + f = y)

Ah, Ill fix that. s + d = w, but s + f = y. Sorry.

I don't think so, I didn't check, but I thought that a cipher that depends on the alphabetical position of encryption characters would be different from any out there

Have you tried it again?

I don't get any error, when I try it, I also cannot see this.

I am fairly certain that I have fixed all of my problems on this kata, but, I am open to any feedback and criticism.

Thank you so much, I hope to create better katas in the future.

I had no idea, thanks. Please explain how to make the random tests and how to create them properly.
I need help, please!

It has been unpublished, once again, I am very sorry guys.

I am very sorry, this is the first kata I have made, and I wan't really sure what I was doing, I had no clue how to make the random tests, and whenever I tried to, I would fail. There is no video helping me through this so I am very sorry that my kata wasn't very good. Thank you for your feedback.