Ad
  • Custom User Avatar

    It is unclear what the actual question is. I only solved it from looking at the sample tests and plugging the info directly in.
    It would be helpful to have the question explicity written after the story, with examples.

  • Custom User Avatar

    Needs random tests

  • Custom User Avatar

    The description is a massive obsfucation to a 8kyu problem. That goes to tell how bad the description is (and why it should really be fixed).

  • Custom User Avatar

    It's a nice story. Some suggestions to improve the kata:

    • Try to split the details into a story, and a task
    • Specify the input, and the desired output in the task
    • Don't give away most of the answer in the sample test cases
    • Add some random tests
  • Custom User Avatar

    Don't take this personally, but I strongly advise you think about whether the katas you publish on CW will add any value to the site and its users.

  • Custom User Avatar

    Cute story.

    However, no random tests, wrong initial code and not original.

    May I draw your attention to Kata Best Practices - Make Sure Content is New ?

  • Custom User Avatar

    Pull this back to Draft and get the tests corrected.

  • Custom User Avatar

    Okay, let's get this straight.

    None of the code (initial code, author solution, test) are correct or functional at all.

    Please unpublish the kata and fix all of them before putting it on beta.

    (The description was nice though. Maybe next time you should spend the effort writing them to an actually interesting and functional kata ;-))